Power Tools  logo

Site Map | IIED | Contact Us
Accessing 'public' information | Good, average, bad: law in action | Improving forest justice | Independent forest monitoring | Legal literacy camps | Local government accountability | People's law
Getting started | Community tradeoffs assessment | Family portraits | Stakeholder power analysis | Stakeholder influence mapping | The four Rs | Writing style: political implications
Avante Consulta! Effective consultation | Better business: market chain workshops | Connecting communities to markets | Ethical appeal | Media and lobby tactics | Speaking for ourselves | Targeting livelihoods evidence | The pyramid
Associations for business partnerships | Mechanisms for organisation | Interactive radio drama | Organsing pitsawyers to engage
subglobal6 link | subglobal6 link | subglobal6 link | subglobal6 link | subglobal6 link | subglobal6 link | subglobal6 link
subglobal7 link | subglobal7 link | subglobal7 link | subglobal7 link | subglobal7 link | subglobal7 link | subglobal7 link

Strengths and Limits of Tools in Practice

A tools focus (as opposed say to a policy focus or a context focus) enables us to think more clearly about not just the aims of a group of people marginalised from policy, but how to achieve those aims.

Tools have many strengths – they:

But tools also have their limits – they:

One of the main lessons from this work is that for most of us, a “tool” is an easy concept to grasp, but expressing what we do in terms of a transferable toolkit that can be picked up, understood and adapted by others is a very difficult task indeed. In general, we focus on our objective – and we design or select the ways of getting there as we go along. Often a method or tactic will only seem to be a tool in retrospect, when we try to describe to others how we achieved a certain goal. Thus what in reality was muddling along suddenly appears well planned and formal when described as a tool.

No single tool is ever perfect. Old, proven, multi-purpose methods continue to offer more utility than new, custom-made techniques. Fully comprehensive, cohesive toolkits that provide approaches for every natural resource policy problem are unfeasible. Concern with the “how to” should not overshadow the goal towards which the tool is used, and taking a tool at face value without considering its legitimacy, context or who is going to use it, can be dangerous. Tools have power – potentially to counter marginalisation, but also to entrench the status quo. Any tool is in the hands of the user to apply and adapt as best they can.

IIED Site Map | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | ©2004 International Institute for Environment and Development